³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ

Yay for a HTML5 based video clip player. Just please ensure that the HTML5 fallback is available to all devices that can play it that don't have Flash, not just the ones that can't have Flash.

More to the point, could we please have HTML5 as the first choice, and Flash as the fallback - on any device that can support both Flash is slower, less reliable, and uses more CPU/battery.

Other than that, sounds good to me.

I hope the content organisation process includes making more local news content available without searching. Often I just want to browse local news from the past month or two without searching for a specific subject.

New Macs do not have Flash installed and I will not install it on my iMac for various reasons so I am unable to watch any video on the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ - I just get an annoying message about needing to install Flash. Ideally I would like to see HTML5 video as the default, but failing that at least make sure it is available to any device that does not have Flash installed. I am looking forward to the day I can watch video on the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ.

This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

When is the recommend feature going to be reinstalled for HYS as this gives a very clear picture of what others are thinking and when is the Farming Today comments board going to be restored, it is now almost 12 months since this has worked!

I'm a very avid reader of this site and find it very good on most levels: content, balance, accuracy and fairness.
The onbe I think it fails on is layout. The person(s) who designed the page are obviously more experienced at designing the printed page rather than one for viewing on a computer screen. The rules laid down by web design guru Jakob Nielsen are broken as follows:
1. The layout design is based on a portrait template, yet computer screens are all landscape in proportion. Therefore viewers need to scroll down the page to see what is at the bottom.
2. The headlines listed under the photographs in the 'More from ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ News' sewction do not line up horizontally making them difficult to scan quickly if you are in a hurry.
3. The use of lots of white space improves the appearance of a printed page, but is annoyingly useless on a computer screen.

More video is fine, but please for the love of the great sky fairy - don't make them start automatically. It uses up bandwidth when on a slower connection, and makes pages unusable at work (my employer is fine with us looking at the news when on breaks, but it has to be silent!).

As an example, I've had the live text page for the Japan quake open on my browser for several days now; every now and then the video will magically start itself back up again, even after I've pressed 'stop' an hour or so earlier (using Firefox 3.6.3 both on Windows XP and Windows 7).

Commentary from your journalists is hugely welcome (far more welcome than the uninformed and frequently bigoted comments you'll get on each story judging by other news websites); but can it not be given its own section on the frontpage, similar to the "Special Reports" section?

Re the live pages - please can you make them accessible to people who don't want video (for bandwidth or noise reasons) - I often want to keep up with the updating text on a story, but find that clicking on the page starts the video as well, which I then need to stop. Occasionally when you swap between several video feeds, one'll start up later too.

It'd be far better if you just had a box where you had to request the video if you wanted it.

I still like the redesign. Everything's nice and clean and unlike some people I don't find it a hassle using my scroll wheel. Certainly there's a lot of research to suggest that shorter lines are easier to read so I understand why it's been done like that. I don't often have my web pages full screen now anyway.

In line with the comments above I've noticed videos autoplaying, but only on pages where the video was the main content, so I assumed it was supposed to do that. Sounds nasty if it's happening all over the place.

I'm a big fan of the blogs, especially where they give an alternative view on ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ content - a great example being Jake Humphrey's presenters-eye-view video blogs. However the same as the twitter guidelines I've heard about, blogs are personal enough that it should be up to the blogger to realise how best to use them, and not blog just because they've been quota'd to post so much a month.

What's the timeline on moving other parts of the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ news site (e.g. Sport) over to the new front end? Hopefully before the Olympics!

Agree with #9 and #10

If I want to watch the video or the live stream I will start it myself. I don't want it to start automatically - it is annoying and slows my computer down.

The last time you redesigned the News pages there was massive criticism. I recall that the blog entries had many 1000 responses with at least 90 % negative. It seems that at the time this was shaked off as being down to "people do not like change", which frankly felt rather patronising.

It is disappointing that in the list above there is no reference to the previous experience and any steps to respond to the feedback in this update. I still believe that the visual layout of the site deminished significantly in the last update. I am all for new technical updates, but the visual layout has got to be improved - ideally made to look like it did before!

Agree with #s 1, 2 and 4: HTML5 video, please!!

Although I have the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ iPad app, not all articles and/or videos on the website are (understandably) available on the app. I mostly use the website, but switch over to the iPad app to see if a video I'm particularly interested in is there, but it isn't always.

The sooner the better!

I feel exactly the same as ironbath, I was sorely grieved by the previous set of changes to the site look and feel and in my opinion the site still looks garish and badly laid out. I shudder to look at it in its current form. I now run a greasemonkey script to restore the site to something resembling the previous incarnation.

The changes to incorporate more of a social feel are welcome as well as increased use of video feeds. However, the use of flash causes problems to some of the Linux machines I use to access the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ site. Your recent changes have caused Firefox on Slackware to lock up when showing the frontpage, on Windows, of course it works as it should.

Overall I am disappointed by the retention of the previous failed experiment to improve the site, at best you just changed it. At worst you bu@@ered it up.

HTML5 - great news. Is there any reason why you wouldn't be able to make this the default format?

³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ correspondents - hmm, will reserve judgment on that one...

Live Pages - glad to hear these incredibly useful pages are getting an update. They could certainly benefit from some design attention. Currently the iframe just feels wrong - unnecessarily narrow and strangely dated. Also count me as another person who dislikes the video starting automatically.

Re. the overall site design, I'm mostly used to this now (particularly since additional content such as analysis frequently seeps into that blank middle column) but there is one design element in particular that I think is almost unforgivably dreadful. If you go to this page...

/news/world-asia-pacific-12763273

...it's the way the sub-navigation bar beneath the headline requires horizontal scrolling. Surely there's a better way to present a navigation bar than this? Why not just let the links wrap onto two lines if necessary? That would make the links easier to notice and easier to click. On that page for instance, there must be a lot of people who don't even know you can scroll across to a "lessons learned" link.

Finally, back to a positive: I think what you've done with reader comments is good. When you first announced you were looking at ways of including comments, I had visions of every news story developing a long tail of ill-informed drivel at the bottom, much like what's happened with Sky News. I know it's deeply unpopular these days to welcome editorial control of user input, but I'm glad you've done what you have in letting the page load on the Editor's Pick, with a separate tab to read all comments. It does a fairly good job of maintaining quality (and before anyone starts, I've seen intelligent conservative and intelligent liberal viewpoints presented there).

Thanks for the update.

HYS has become a fairly bland offerring of late. You seem to be steering clear of controversial topics and doing the Government's bidding.

We are approaching local elections, an AV referendum, the reform of the NHS, and other key issues and you seem to be ignoring them The Lib Dem conference was ignored, the BMA views on the NHS are just reported with no opportunity to comment on HYS.

The ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ appears to be towing the line.

LINKING - AN IDEA - would you be so kind to make the software OPEN a link in a NEW WINDOW. At the moment you have keep using the BACK BUTTON to navigate back to the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ site. If you have a NEW WINDOW that you retain the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ page. Thank you.

Correspondent #7 has it just right. Your last webpage redesign filled my screen with lots of white space meaning that I now spend far too long scrolling up and down to see what used to be on the side of each main ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ webpage. Please remember that, unlike on paper, computer screens are significantly wider than they are deep and that white space is an iritation to your viewer if it means they have to scroll down to find the items they want!

Keep up the good work, you are doing a very good job. Well worth the license fee.

Echoing others....

Please, please:
HTML5 by default
Video clips not auto starting (or implement a cookie that lets individuals turn that behavior off)
More use of the page width
A reduction in white space (but not anything like back to the previous version, however)

It's already a very good offering, but there is still room to improve.

Are you guys for real?

Are you telling us you (partially) introduced comments, are (starting) to work on metadata, are thinking of linking to other websites?

What is this 2002 or something?

One thing that always intrigues me is that if you click on a link to an external website from within ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ News it opens on the same tab, rather than a new one. You must lose loads of traffic because of that.

I would love to see HTML 5 video as soon as possible on all the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ News pages. The less Flash usage the better, both speed and battery are big considerations when viewing pages on the move.

I have tried using three different browsers on the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ News website and with all three of them there is very little difference between the colour of the text of clicked and un-clicked links. They are both a darkish blue, this makes it difficult to distinguish between stories which I have read and those I have not.

jek19cat and dr-who-21: the links on the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ website don't "open in the same tab" - they open however you tell your browser to open them. What they don't do is take that choice away from you by forcing the issue one way. This is a good thing. If you want to open a link in a new tab, then do so; it's entirely up to you.

While you're at it, can we please go back to the far more legible Verdana font(as used on this page!) instead of Arial?

What video codec are you going to use for HTML5 videos? And I know it's unlikely, but I hope you won't switch completely to HTML5-based videos without providing support for Adobe Flash since the standard codec (I assume you're going to use H.264) will not work with Chrome or Firefox (both are my default browsers).

Could we please have a "email Us about somehting on this page" type contact on EVERY single page that will automatically go to the relevant dept/person and give them the URL of the page in question.

I hate it when I see something that needs attention or comment etc but I have to hunt around to find how to contact the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ and whether it will get to the correct dept. If you really want interaction on you output make it easy.

I'm a bit excited about the mention of HTML5 video - I not infrequently try to watch a video clip on the site, but as or more often than not, it fails to play (usually just a forever-spinning circle-swipe perhaps 65% of the last five years' worth of tries) - I'm in the USA and using a Mac, so I've never known whether it's a Mac issue, whether access would be better if I were in the UK (but, it's fantastic for me to get anything from ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ, being neither a British taxpayer nor a licence fee payer; naturally it's only right if traffic to UK is in fact prioritized), or what the problem may be. Basically it seems Flash is really dodgy, so the prospect of having non-Flash video is highly appealing (hopefully justifiably so). I ardently second the comment begging for non-automatically playing video clips. Sometimes a video starts playing in the background and it's very inconvenient; if I want to watch it, I'll hit 'play' accordingly, and I would expect a majority to agree it's better that way.

Finally, I do so wish the "social" trendiness would be mostly axed - comments on blogs are mostly by disgruntled & obnoxiously-opinionated blowhards, not thoughtful people or people interested in being reasonable; in my non-unique view this phenomenon is significantly corrosive to public discourse and to social engagement generally (potentially in Britain as well as the USA and elsewhere). I submit that the more isolated we all are behind a screen and the more we consequently see "others in society" to be angry, unreasonable, and careless, the more we ourselves will become disengaged and disheartened with the potential of social engagement and the less we will want to try to be decent, engaged persons ourselves. Personal example: I've written some unusually thoughtful and lengthy posts to ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ blog discussions a few times, fairly foolishly, and the response and other posts largely made me feel hopeless about the state of the world. But, perhaps not everybody out there is as mean and careless and disinterested in being reasonable as the motley bunch who habitually post little screeds online. Nevertheless social perception being what it is, it's really disheartening to have these experiences - I know that I'm not the only one and that in fact many, many people have felt this way at least sometimes in the last decade. So maybe we could do what would be good for ourselves rather that what feels good, and not have so much "social" or so much "internet" in general? It's easy and a kick, but how good is it for the state of societies and our lives? (I'm sure if anything I'll be ridiculed by snide 22-year old hipsters as anachronistic, but the disinterest in thinking directly and perceptively about the consequences of what we do is the big problem here, so I say no genuine points scored for trotting out the typical reactionary laissez-faire McWorldviews.) When "public engagement" is primarily people complaining that the news isn't what they wish it were, and militating for journalists who write what they dislike hearing to be disciplined or sacked, it's really not a wonderful new chapter in human communication. Neither is it neutral and harmless thrills. Big, negative social and cultural change usually happens with lots of the little things that are easy to dismiss by anyone who doesn't want there to be a problem. We're changed more and faster by things others say than we like to admit. It doesn't do us much credit, but that doesn't mean it isn't true.

As with others I am echoing the call for HTML5 first, Flash second. It is possible and has been done for some time now.

- Provides HTML5 with Flash and Silverlight fallback options that all implement the same JavaScript API. Has subtitle support too. You should fork this and modify for your needs.

- Another alternative that provides HTML5 first, Flash second.

- My code that implements the core HTML5 to Flash Fallback that both of the above use. I wrote this in June of 2009. You should at _least_ be using this as the core nugget of your implementation and then adding your polish on top of it.

Just because a platform can run Flash doesn't mean it's there or it's wanted. Many people run a Flash blocker, don't have Flash installed, or it didn't come installed on their computer when they bought it.

Will the HTML 5 video format be supported on the iPhone?

'28. At 01:12am on 17 Mar 2011, Patrick wrote:
Could we please have a "email Us about somehting on this page" type contact on EVERY single page that will automatically go to the relevant dept/person and give them the URL of the page in question.

Nice notion. Totally approve/agree.

However one fears even a factual correction may get viewed as a complaint, and there is already a vast and labyrinthine system designed to ensure those get progressed in the most, er, 'appropriate' manner without pretty heads getting troubled by facing up to the calibre of what is almost exclusively broadcast only.

I see plenty of calls for HTML 5 here when it is not fully implemented on browsers yet. That aside, there are several things the Beeb could do to bring their content up to date with even the most basic of free Content Management systems.

Proper Templating

So we don't have this idiocy of older stories appearing in a different template to modern stories. I assume this is because it was decided to store the template with the story, or some other daft idea.

When you change the template for the site, the idea is that it changes for ALL that content type.

Image Light Box

Even on my blog several years ago when you click on my images, the full sized version opens in a modal window - quite why this had not made it to the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ news site is beyond me.

Categorisation and Taxomony

I see this is mentioned above, but again, this is the sort of really obvious content management that has been around for a long time.

Article Edit history

It is maddening to go to an article and find it has been updated, but with not comment as to when and so on. Updating content is perfectly legitimate, but it is simply polite to show a record of when it was first published and when it was updated - especially for legal stories.

I see you want to expand commenting on articles - another thing most people had on news sites 12 years ago. The only issue here is whether you have enough moderators to cope!

Less White Space

The current template wastes so much space it is criminal. Apart from making the site look sparse and badly formatted, it increases the amount of scrolling as everything is spread out.

One Paragraph per Sentence

This is fine for a headline, but not for the body. It does not make things more readable. If your page is unreadable without spreading it out, then you are using the wrong font. Adding extra space makes it look tatty.

Other Common Features:

Email Link to page
Print Article
PDF

Now you may have copyright problems with some of these, but again, this is old stuff and helps give content longevity.


Have fun!

Just another person who dislikes the video starting automatically. You could fix it on new pages this without appearing to have lost face.

wow, all those changes.... but it looks like it is getting even more difficult to "have my say"... I cannot find a way in anymore, other than via one of the editor's blogs where someone has already commented.
Looks like the only way to have my say or comment other than that now is via sms or twitter. and I steadfastedly refuse to join the latter. shame....

I see plenty of calls for HTML 5 here when it is not fully implemented on browsers yet.

Chicken and egg problem. Someone's got to jump first, and taking that sort of lead on technical matters has always been part of the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ's role. Any idea how many people had TVs when the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ started broadcasting to them?

In any case, the strongest calls have been for HTML5 with a Flash fallback, so it's not as though anyone's suggesting breaking things.

This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

If the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ wish to improve their business blogs they may want to have another individual option running alongside Robert Peston - I don't mean Stephanie Flanders as she does a great job.

Nick Robinson too? Perhaps he needs more competition on his political reporting from the Westminster village?

Imagine if Robert Peston and Nick Robinson disappeared tomorrow? Who are they mentoring right now? If not, why not?

6. At 4:15pm on 16 Mar 2011, Lynn from Sussex wrote:
"When is the recommend feature going to be reinstalled for HYS as this gives a very clear picture of what others are thinking and when is the Farming Today comments board going to be restored, it is now almost 12 months since this has worked!"

I was hoping it wasn't. If we must have this feature, it would be good to be able to "unrecommend" posts.

My experience of this feature is that it allowed comments that were often dumbed-down and childish to reach the number one spot and that it was misused by fringe political groups in an attempt to appear meainstream.

Steve, some really great improvements - particularly the "metadata" piece - having a proper tagging and classification system will make life much easier for those of us who use ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ as a research source of sorts. There is a wealth of content already produced and it's currently close to impossible accessing the relevant material using just google or the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ search facility.

About the video, I would be curious to know if people based outside the UK will be able to access these as it appears some of this content is shut out by ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ with geotargeting?

Mze ()

This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

Steve, is there any chance of having widgets on the sidebar that would allow us to select twitter feeds from various ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ reporters (that would basically stream tweets in the sidebar from those reporters).

I imagine users would need to have cookies enabled for this feature, but for those of us who spend a long time on the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ site each day it would be a welcome addition!

"³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ News website developments".

Welcome to the sister site of crushing HYS?

This comment was removed because the moderators found it broke the house rules. Explain.

Another request for video not to start automatically. I want to read what's on the page & choose whether or not to watch the video. It's very irritating to have to wait for the video to load before I can even scroll down the page.

It's taken me a while to notice this blog post because I rarely visit the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ news site these days.

I'm all for the technical improvements you describe - really happy to see those on the way. However, I'm afraid I still loathe the new design. I was really unhappy when it came out, despite previously being a bit of a ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ fanboy. I liked all the previous evolutions, but this one still fails for me.

I even like the idea of the GVL/GEL - but I don't like the design itself (basically too big/chunky, nowhere near elegant enough and I could go on). I've expressed my views before, but nobody takes any notice. I hope that I'm in the minority and that it is just my taste that is at fault and that most people love it.

Sadly for me, the result is that I'm a lot less of a regular user than I used to be. I drift through the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ News site and others from time to time, but they are no longer the *must visit* sites they once were. I now use another site as my primary news source.

I only hope that in a year or two, the GEL will get an overhaul and produce something better. At that point I will take another look.

Sorry but feeling sad that my comments never seem to have been heard or responded to. :(

BTW, some of us like the white space. Going on to a webpage that is densely packed with pictures, clips and info is a sure-fire trigger for a migraine.

And leave HYS alone, you phillistines!

Perhaps you should also consider making Android apps as a means of improving the website interactivity... This is now being discussed on several Android blogs, with in particular wanting to see some cool apps for news & user interaction. I think this is imperative nowadays for any website that wants to keep up with the speed of developments.