Argentine trailblazers
It's now 30 years since, fresh from winning the World Cup, and left Argentina and touched down at White Hart Lane.
Tottenham's coup was years ahead of its time. Just a few months later Paul Weller, in the 'Strange Town' would take an alienated wander along Oxford Street and complain that he felt like "a spaceman from those UFOs. And he was from Woking. What would it be like for Ardiles and Villa coming from the other side of the Atlantic?
The great and the good of the English game queued up to proclaim that it would never work.
The exotic new acquisitions wouldn't like it up 'em (had they not seen the free for all between Brazil and Argentina in that year's World Cup?) and anyway, the weather would be too cold (though Buenos Aires in July can feel like wandering round inside a fridge).
In the event the pair were a huge hit. In his shorter spell Villa had moments of powerful elegance, while Ardiles gave a decade-long masterclass in shielding and moving the ball.
In their wake came a smattering of their compatriots, with varying degrees of success. And then it all went quiet.
Clearly, in the case of players from Argentina, relations were damaged by the 1982 Falklands War. But, bar the odd fleeting here and there, there were no South Americans from anywhere else in the continent to be found in English football.
On the one hand, English clubs seemed to have forgotten the ease with which Ardiles adapted, and the extra skill and ideas he brought. On the other, South Americans were hardly enticed by English football in its crisis years during the 1980s.
With the financial reorganisation and the boom of the Premiership that began to change. Word quickly gets round the international football community. When I moved to South America in 1994 the wish list of players looking for a move to Europe (then as now nearly all of them) was comprised of just Italy and Spain.
As the 90s wore on it suddenly became 'Italy, Spain and England' - and not necessarily in that order.
It's taken time, but just over a decade into this process the Premiership kicks off 2008/9 campaign as a truly global concern.
are no longer the occasional tropical attraction. Now they are a normal and accepted part of the English scene, ready to make a contribution similar to the one they have long made to all the other major European leagues.
The tipping point was reached last season. It was the year the latest pair of Argentine amigos, Javier Mascherano and , established themselves in top four clubs.
Blackburn Rovers resurrected the career of Paraguay's Roque Santa Cruz, as did Manchester City with Brazil's Elano. Manchester United attracted and adapted Anderson, a potential Brazilian superstar, and Liverpool blooded Lucas, Brazil's big central midfield hope.
Work permit difficulties continue to limit the flow, and cross-culture moves are by their very nature a gamble. But increasingly Premiership clubs are seeing South Americans as a gamble worth taking.
They have discovered, for example, that these days Brazil is a top class producer of goalkeepers. Gomes is already popular with Tottenham fans, and Liverpool have Diego Cavalieri as their back up.
is a big money signing for Manchester City, there are Argentines on the Tyne with Jonas Gutierrez and Fabricio Coloccini joining Newcastle. And if all these players have European experience, that's not the case with left footed playmaker , plucked straight out of Chile by Blackburn.
Looking further north, now there are even Mexicans in the Premiership. Giovani Dos Santos and Carlos Vela, so impressive in harness three years ago when Mexico won the World Under-17 Cup, .
And then there is Luiz Felipe Scolari calling the shots at Chelsea. Ardiles managed some English clubs, and Gus Poyet is assistant at Tottenham. But they both paid their dues in the English game as players.
Scolari is different. High profile, charismatic, but with no experience of European club football, the Brazilian comes straight in to take charge of a club where honours are now expected.
Scolari at the Bridge emphatically highlights the fact that, 30 years on from Ardiles and Villa, the English game has opened its doors to South Americans.
Your questions answered:
My Brazilian mate reckons that Renan of Internacional will play for Brazil one day. A lot of good Brazilian keepers around - any chance of him making it?
Alistair Hattingh. Ohio
Every chance. He was one of the successes (along with right back Rafinha) in a poor Under-20 Brazil team in 2005, and he's doing himself no harm at all with his Olympic performances - unbeaten so far after two games, and he needed to be sharp a couple of times in the debut v Belgium.
It's putting him in the shop window, and European clubs are interested. Perhaps as well as looking at Brazilian goalkeepers, English clubs might do well to investigate Brazilian methods of goalkeeping preparation.
What do you think of Brazilian centre back Thiago Silva?
Alexander Bentil, Ghana
A very, very classy defender - he's also at the Olympics, as one of Brazil's overage players, but so far he's been injured. He oozes quality, recovers well, is good on the ball.
When he goes back to Europe (he had illness blighted spells in Portugal and Russia) there is something he will have to work on, though. He positions himself very deep, almost on top of the goalkeeper. In the long term I think he'll have to work out how to defend higher up the field.
Comment number 1.
At 11th Aug 2008, Matt Newsum - ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ Sport wrote:Great to see The Jam mentioned Tim - football and great music in harmony!
On the subject of South Americans up here, it's interesting having seen early glimpses of Gutierrez how much like an old-fashioned winger he seems to be.
In the games I've seen so far, he's been running at full-backs, teasing them with pace and skill and seems like an excellent acquisition. What are your thoughts?
I'm excited to see Villanueva in action... hope he manages to get a game under Ince.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 1)
Comment number 2.
At 11th Aug 2008, ViewFromThePaddock wrote:Any info on QPR's new found Argentinian, Emmanuel Jorge Ledesma? Sounds like we plucked him from Genoa's reserves, but it looks like he's got the flair to be a very exciting addition to the Championship (when the weather's nice anyway).
Complain about this comment (Comment number 2)
Comment number 3.
At 11th Aug 2008, ArthurBalfour wrote:I have happy memories of Ossie and Ricky coming to London. My father is Argentine and a Spurs fan, so when the Spurs duo arrived in London, he volunteered his services to the club and acted as an unofficial guide to both of them. Back in those days London was not the cosmopolitan city that it is now, and Buenos Aires may as well have been a different planet. No mate, no dulce de leche, no churros and no pizza.
I remember Ossie as being slightly reserved, but Ricky was a proper Porteno. What a shame the Falklands happened and destroyed so much goodwill between the countries.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 3)
Comment number 4.
At 11th Aug 2008, thoult wrote:As usual, another interesting and well put together column from Mr Vickery. If only the articles covering top flight domestic football were as good!
Having visited Venezuela on holiday during the 2006 World Cup and seen the locals' passion for the game, I was interested to hear earlier this summer that Wigan were interested in the young Maracaibo forward Daniel Arismendi.
How do you think Arismendi would fare in the Premier League? Would he work well with the other South Americans in the squad?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 4)
Comment number 5.
At 11th Aug 2008, U11947716 wrote:It really is true that vickery is the best of the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ's sport pundits and columnists
- keep it coming!
What South American nations do you think produce players most suited to English football though- Both culturally and on the pitch?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 5)
Comment number 6.
At 11th Aug 2008, ArgentinaBlade wrote:Nice one Mr Vickery - my wife is Argentine (we got married in May) and I met her when I travelled for a year through the whole of South America in 2005-6 (a well earned sabbatical from the NHS). I think I was probably out there due to admiring Ardiles, Villa and most importantly Alex Sabella for Sheff Utd as a kid (I remember Sabella used to always play with no shin pads and his socks rolled down so we all used to copy him and get in trouble).
We are due a late honeymoon out with her family in Cordoba at Christmas and hope to catch a game, I've been to the Bombonera when Boca won the league at the end of 2005 but I have had to switch allegiances due to her Dad been River through and through. Fortunately, he is now an ardent Blade follower....
Always love the articles keep up the good work!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 6)
Comment number 7.
At 11th Aug 2008, SuperUwe wrote:The subject of South Americans in British football is a funny old one really.
I think at club level though it is really such a mixed bag; for example at Southampton we have not had any luck at all in signing South Americans.
Of course our experience is probably tainted by the one man wonder that is Agustin Delgado! We could never get him fit and more to the point there were a number of crazy issues surrounding his pivotal role for Ecuador which meant that he never really had a chance.
Personally I don't think it matters too much where you come from, if you can adapt to the language, climate and culture, you will do fine. Most players that are bought over from South America do have decent pedigree, but often it is the mental side of things that seems to cause problems (our one remaining S.A, Jhon Viafara, is apparently trying to get a return back to Colombia, so we are just not doing very well!).
Complain about this comment (Comment number 7)
Comment number 8.
At 11th Aug 2008, meomyone wrote:It does bring it all back...we just came up from Division 2 as it was in those days...No Premiership with poncy name then...I remember the first home match too. We got thumped 4-0 by Villa...But to your correspondent who commented on the London scene at the time, I can assure you that Tottenham at that time was as cosmopolitan as it gets. Round where I lived, just off White Hart Lane, I had friends and colleagues from Europe, Americas, Aussies, Kiwis, Asians and Africa. And....now wait for it....we had a Pizza Hut just up the road in Stamford Hill and one of the first places in London to get a Mac's.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 8)
Comment number 9.
At 11th Aug 2008, ScammellCrusader wrote:At about the same time Birmingham City signed Alberto Tarantini who was a left-back in the same Argentinian World Cup winning team.
I seem to remember that even though nominally a left-back, Taratnini would often finish matches ppalying as a triker for Birmingham.
Those were the days, eh!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 9)
Comment number 10.
At 11th Aug 2008, Boroborn89 wrote:A very good article. Although it is maybe a biased opinion but i believe the success juninho paulista had at middlesbrough would have also had an impact on the introduction of south americans in england and probably deserves a lot more credit than he gets from anywhere outside of teesside.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 10)
Comment number 11.
At 11th Aug 2008, benitezbeard wrote:Argentine magic or not, i can remember when Ardiles and co came to Anfield in 1978 and were thumped 7-0... the last goal was as good as anything i've ever seen Argentina do. They must have wondered what they'd got themselves into!
On a side note the gaining interest in the North American soccer league looks to be parallel to that of the late 70s too. Remember when British players used to go out there to play in the summer? All of these things are well covered in the fantastic 'Football Handbook' compilation that came out a year or so ago, great nostalgia from the time i was just getting into football, in the late 70s.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 11)
Comment number 12.
At 12th Aug 2008, alky_celtzer wrote:I had just moved to London and I went along to their first game (first home game?) against Aston Villa. Villa blew them away 4-1, with Brian Little scoring a great goal. Seem to recall Ardiles having a half-decent match.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 12)
Comment number 13.
At 12th Aug 2008, Cocteau8 wrote:First game of the season was against the then champions, Notts Forest, at the City Ground, with Villa surprising us all by outshining Ardiles and scoring the equaliser. Should have won, as well (the late Ian Moores missed a sitter - unlike him!). Things went down hill from there though - the Villa and Liverpool defeats and getting knocked out at home, against Swansea, in the League Cup!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 13)
Comment number 14.
At 12th Aug 2008, StratfordBlade wrote:Great article, but of course the whole thing was brokered and arranged by the late Harry Haslam, who was then manager of Sheffield United. He had sorted a scouting system in Argentina headed by the notorious Antonio Rattin, and had identified players he would sign when the World Cup had finished. He initially wanted a young 16 yeard old he'd seen, argued with the Argentine FA about releasing the youngster and agreed a then staggering fee of £400,000 for the child prodigy. Alas, the Blades board baulked at the fee for a 16 year old, and young Diego stayed in Argentina!!!
After such a prominent world cup, United could no longer afford Ardiles and Villa, so Haslam contacted Keith Burkinshaw and they signed for Spurs. We got the unknown Alex Sabella, good player, lots of craft and skill, but not really suited to the old Division 2 of the late 70s.
Complain about this comment (Comment number 14)
Comment number 15.
At 12th Aug 2008, 1978 Shoot league ladders wrote:Still say it was Hutchinson who won them the FA Cup though, bah!
Complain about this comment (Comment number 15)
Comment number 16.
At 12th Aug 2008, ironWilliamOfOrange wrote:Undoubtedly the best columnist on the ³ÉÈË¿ìÊÖ. Well done Tim, it's always a real insightful read - and does make Monday mornings at work that bit easier to swallow. South American football is so fascinating, and an aspect of the world game that we don't see enough of. Not sure why this is, perhaps the lack of British colonial history in the region? Over the years the articles have been very good and you must be commended for this. But it must be tough living in Rio though ;)
Complain about this comment (Comment number 16)
Comment number 17.
At 26th Aug 2008, shivam_mufc7 wrote:who cares?
Complain about this comment (Comment number 17)