What is wrong with this sentence?
鈥業t was sports day the sun was shining.鈥
Important punctuation is missing.
One way it could be punctuated correctly is: 鈥業t was sports day. The sun was shining.鈥
Introduction to independent clauses
An independent clauseAn independent clause is a group of words that work by themselves as a sentence. is a group of words that work by themselves as a sentence. A simple sentenceA simple sentence consists of one independent clause. consists of one independent clause.
When joining independent clauses, a common mistake is to use a comma or no punctuation. There are several solutions to punctuate them correctly.
What is an independent clause?
An independent clause is a clause that can stand alone as a complete sentence. For example: Jenny ran the race well.
They can also be joined to make longer sentences.
What are the common mistakes when punctuating an independent clause?
Most mistakes occur when joining two independent clauses when using a comma (sometimes called comma splicing) or no punctuation (called a run-on sentence).
An example of comma splicing: 鈥楯enny ran the race well, she came third overall.鈥
An example of a run-on sentence: 鈥楯enny ran the race well she came third overall.鈥
How should you do it?
You could do any of the following:
- Write two complete sentences.
Example: 鈥楯enny ran the race well. She came third overall.鈥
- Use a comma and a coordinating conjunction
Example: 鈥楯enny ran the race well, but she came third overall.鈥
- Use a semicolon
Example: 鈥楯enny ran the race well; she came third overall.鈥
- Use a subordinate conjunction
Example 1: 鈥When Jenny ran the race well, she came third overall.鈥
Example 2: 鈥楯enny ran the race well, although she came third overall.鈥
When do writers break the rules?
Fiction writers, poets and speech makers might break these rules of punctuation to create particular effects.
For example, in dialogue and first-person narration, a character might be breathless, excited or upset and so speak quickly. The tiny pause created by a comma can clarify sentence structure (so the reader can understand it) whilst clearly showing the character鈥檚 rushing speech or thoughts.
For example:
- A panicking character might tell themselves to: "Think, think, think."
- In the middle of intense action, a character might say: "Just hold on, wait, now go!"
Traditionally, poems often used commas at the end of lines of verse. Commas help to separate ideas but do not interrupt the flow. Look at this example from The Rime of the Ancient Mariner by Samuel Taylor Coleridge:
Water, water, every where,
And all the boards did shrink;
Water, water, every where,
Nor any drop to drink.
More famous examples:
One of the most famous openings to a novel, A Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens uses comma splicing throughout:
It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of foolishness.
Why is it effective?
The commas help to create a long list of opposites: 'best' and 'worst', 'wisdom' and 'foolishness'. Using a series of commas, instead of full stops or other punctuation, keeps building the main idea that it was a time period of opposites and contradictions.
Another famous example, this time from a speech, is when Julius Caesar, reporting back to Rome after winning a battle, famously said in Latin, 鈥淰eni, vidi, vici鈥 which translates as 鈥淚 came, I saw, I conquered鈥.
Why is it effective?
The use of commas to break up the three short clauses helps to suggest that he was a great military leader and that it was easy for him to win in just three steps.
Different ways to punctuate independent clauses
Test your knowledge
Play Bitesize secondary games. gamePlay Bitesize secondary games
Have fun playing science, maths, history, geography and language games.
More on Punctuation
Find out more by working through a topic
- count11 of 11
- count1 of 11
- count2 of 11
- count3 of 11